DNS Resolvers Are The Wrong Place To Fight Piracy
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

TL;DR

Quad9 says it will stop answering DNS queries from France on Nov. 24, 2026, after a Paris court imposed a €1,000-per-day penalty over its refusal to block pirate-streaming domains. The case highlights a dispute over whether DNS resolvers should be required to enforce copyright blocks, and what those orders mean for services used for security and privacy.

Quad9, the Swiss nonprofit that operates the free 9.9.9.9 DNS resolver, says it will stop answering queries from France on Nov. 24, 2026, after a Paris court imposed a €1,000-per-day penalty over its failure to block domains linked to pirate sports streams. The move would remove a public resolver used for security filtering and privacy from French networks, as the dispute tests how far copyright blocking orders can reach beyond internet service providers.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

According to the report by TechStackups, the penalty was imposed on Oct. 21 in a case involving an earlier blocking order. The source says Quad9 was ordered to block domains associated with pirate sports-streaming services on behalf of beIN Sports. Quad9 has said it cannot afford to continue operating in France while facing this and other cases. The report describes about 20 similar cases as pending, though it does not provide details for each one.

A DNS resolver translates a domain name into the numerical address a device uses to connect to a website. Quad9 also uses threat-intelligence feeds to block domains associated with malware, phishing and botnet activity. The company says it does not keep user records. Its withdrawal means French users whose devices or networks rely on 9.9.9.9 may need to switch resolvers. The source warns that users may not receive a clear notice if the service stops responding; the effect could instead appear as websites failing to load.

France’s Article L.333-10 allows sports rightsholders to seek dynamic blocking orders. The source says these orders can cover additional domains identified later through Arcom, the French media regulator. It also reports that a July 2026 law introduced an automated, real-time blocking system administered by Arcom. The specific legal reasoning behind the latest penalty, and the precise terms of Quad9’s planned withdrawal, are not fully laid out in the material provided.

At a glance
updateWhen: Announced ahead of Nov. 24, 2026; the c…
The developmentQuad9 has announced that it will withdraw its DNS resolver service from France after a Paris court imposed a daily penalty tied to orders requiring it to block piracy-related domains.

When DNS Becomes a Copyright Enforcer

The dispute matters because DNS resolvers sit between users and nearly every website they visit. A court order aimed at a resolver can affect access for people and organisations that use it for reasons unrelated to piracy, including its security filtering and privacy features. Those effects may be difficult for users to diagnose if a resolver simply stops answering queries.

The case also raises a practical problem for a service designed to operate across borders: if it cannot apply a block only to users in France, it may have to block a domain for users elsewhere or withdraw from the country. The source says Quad9 has previously blocked some ordered domains globally because it could not geolocate users. That is an account of Quad9’s position, not a court finding about the effects of every order.

For readers, the immediate consequence is not that all French internet access will stop. It is that people and networks configured to use Quad9 may lose that resolver and need an alternative. More broadly, the case may shape whether intermediaries beyond ISPs—including public DNS services and VPN providers—are expected to carry out sports-piracy blocks.

Products Worth Considering

Jackery Explorer 1000 v2 Portable Power Station, 1024Wh LiFePO4 Battery

Jackery Explorer 1000 v2 Portable Power Station, 1024Wh LiFePO4 Battery

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

How French Blocking Orders Expanded

The source traces the dispute to Law 2021-1382, which introduced Article L.333-10 of the sports code. The provision allows sports rights holders to seek court orders against people or services able to help stop infringement. In 2023, Canal+ brought a case against Cloudflare, Google and Cisco. The Paris court ordered blocks in 2024; Google complied, while Cisco withdrew its OpenDNS service from France.

In December 2024, Canal+ obtained orders involving Quad9 and Vercara. The source says Quad9 blocked the affected domains worldwide because it lacked a way to limit the blocks geographically. A May 2025 beIN request against several providers was rejected for lack of evidence, according to the report. In March 2026, the Paris Court of Appeal rejected five appeals by Google, Cloudflare and Cisco, upholding DNS blocking under the law. The report says further orders later reached ISPs, resolvers, VPN providers and Bing.

Quad9 is not the only resolver affected. The source says a 2026 order against DNS4EU, a European Union-funded resolver, led it to block domains globally across its resolver tiers. These examples show the widening range of services drawn into French sports-rights cases; they do not establish that every provider has responded in the same way.

“a canary in the coal mine”

— Cloudflare, as quoted in the TechStackups report

What the Withdrawal Will Change

The source says Quad9 plans to stop answering queries from France on Nov. 24, but the material does not specify exactly how the service will identify French queries or what users will see during the change. It also does not provide Quad9’s full announcement or the complete text of the Oct. 21 ruling, so the legal basis and scope of the €1,000 daily penalty cannot be independently detailed here.

The report refers to around 20 similar French cases still pending, but does not name all parties, list each case’s status or explain whether any could be resolved before the withdrawal date. It is also unclear whether Quad9 will challenge the latest order, seek a change to its terms, or restore service if the legal situation changes. The report’s account of consequences for users is a forecast, not confirmation that every French Quad9 user will lose access in the same way.

The Nov. 24 Service Deadline

The stated next milestone is Nov. 24, 2026, when Quad9 says it will stop responding to DNS queries from France. French users and organisations that have configured devices or networks to use 9.9.9.9 may need to choose another resolver before then. The source does not say whether Quad9 will provide migration guidance or notify affected organisations directly.

Further developments may come from the pending French cases, any legal challenge by Quad9, or decisions by other DNS providers facing similar orders. The available material does not establish what those providers will do. The practical outcome will depend on the final terms of the relevant orders and whether Quad9’s planned withdrawal proceeds as announced.

Key Questions

What is Quad9?

Quad9 is a nonprofit public DNS resolver available at 9.9.9.9. It translates domain names into the addresses devices use to reach websites and says it blocks domains associated with malware, phishing and botnets.

Why is Quad9 leaving France?

According to the TechStackups report, a Paris court imposed a €1,000-per-day penalty after Quad9 did not comply with an order to block domains linked to pirate sports streams. Quad9 says it plans to stop answering French queries on Nov. 24, 2026.

Will French internet access stop working?

No. The reported change concerns users and networks that rely on Quad9 specifically, not all internet access in France. Those users may need to select another DNS resolver; the source says the disruption could appear as websites failing to load.

What are DNS blocking orders?

They require a DNS provider to stop resolving specified domain names, which can prevent users of that resolver from reaching those domains by name. France’s Article L.333-10 allows sports rights holders to seek orders that can include additional domains identified later through Arcom.

What is still unknown?

The available material does not give the full ruling or explain exactly how Quad9 will implement its withdrawal. The status of about 20 pending cases, and whether Quad9 may challenge or change its plans, also remains unclear.

Source: techstackups.com

You May Also Like

14 Best Wireless Gaming Mice For Different Play Styles In 2027

A buying guide compares 14 wireless gaming mice by shape, controls, battery, and connectivity, while noting conflicting product specifications.

How The Community Safety Report Covers Teen Protections

An OpenAI page is titled “Community safety report and new protections for teens,” but its findings, measures and timing cannot be verified from available details.

The Role Of Seed AI In ByteDance’s Robotics Hiring Drive

Tech in Asia reports increased robotics hiring through ByteDance’s Seed AI unit, but the scale, roles and projects involved are not specified.

Take-Two’s CEO On Why Cloning Games With AI Seems ‘Ironic’

Strauss Zelnick said AI companies should protect others’ intellectual property and described game cloning as a creative concern, not a financial threat.