🔍 Read the full analysis: How Publishers’ Rights Fit Into The EU Debate On AI Chatbots on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
TL;DR
On November 3, 2026, Advocate General Maciej Szpunar advised the EU Court of Justice that chatbots retrieving and reusing news articles may infringe press publishers’ rights in certain circumstances. He said the test is not met on the facts described in the Gemini case, and the Hungarian court will decide after the EU court issues a binding judgment.
Advocate General Maciej Szpunar advised the Court of Justice of the European Union on November 3 that chatbots which retrieve online news articles and reuse them in answers may infringe press publishers’ rights in certain circumstances. In Case C‑250/25, Like Company v Google Ireland, he said infringement may arise if a service bypasses barriers to access or reproduces an article’s distinctive expression so extensively that users can avoid visiting the original, but his assessment suggests those conditions are not met in the dispute over a Gemini summary.
The case was brought by Like Company, which operates Hungarian news portals, against Google. According to the Court of Justice’s press release, Like Company alleges that Google used its articles to train Gemini and repeatedly reproduced and made them available through the chatbot between June 13, 2023, and May 31, 2024. Those are the publisher’s allegations, not findings by the court.
The dispute began after Gemini produced a Hungarian summary of a Like Company article about a singer’s reported plan to bring dolphins to Lake Balaton. The article was published in July 2023. Szpunar’s opinion distinguishes between reporting the same facts, which are not protected in themselves, and reusing the article’s protected form of expression. He said answers may infringe if they retain wording or expression recognisable enough that a user can dispense with the original publication.
He also identified a separate access question: a chatbot may infringe if it obtained an article by circumventing a paywall or an anti-scraping measure. In the example before him, however, the opinion says there appear to be no access barriers, no recognisable wording in the answer, and safeguards at Google. The opinion is advisory and does not decide the case.
Infographic 01 · Where the line runs
When a chatbot answer infringes a publisher's right
Advocate General Szpunar's test in Case C‑250/25 for chatbots that retrieve news articles in real time and reuse them in their answers.
Stays free
- Reporting the same facts. Nobody owns the news itself (pts 199–200).
- A short factual summary, presented differently (pt 208).
- An overview built from several sources, restructured, with links back (pts 208, 234).
- Individual words or very short extracts (pt 201).
Can infringe
- Getting around a paywall or anti-scraping block to fetch the article (pt 188).
- An answer that keeps the article’s structure and phrasing, even paraphrased, so readers can skip the original (pts 202, 205, 207).
- Systematically recognisable articles in answers to related questions: making available to the public (pts 213, 240).
The test, step by step
For a chatbot that fetches a news article live (RAG) and answers a user
- Is it an online use by a service in the EU?Yes for RAG answers to EU users, wherever the servers are (pts 165–169).
- Did the bot get in lawfully?No circumvention of effective technical measures (pt 188).
- Is the article’s form of expression recognisable in the answer, to the point of substitution?Side-by-side comparison; facts do not count (pts 196–209).
- Is the provider responsible?If inherent to its business model, or no reasonable measures such as respecting blocks and output filters (pts 221–222).
- Temporary copies during retrieval are then exempt under Art. 5(1) InfoSoc; the TDM exception does not apply to RAG (pts 179–189).
An Advocate General’s opinion, not a judgment. General information, not legal advice.
Sources: Opinion of AG Szpunar, C‑250/25 (provisional text), CURIA press release No 155/26 (3 Nov 2026). Point numbers refer to the provisional text.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
The Line Between Summary and Copy
The opinion gives publishers and AI services a framework for a dispute that is becoming central to the use of news online: when does a chatbot’s answer reuse a publication, rather than simply convey information found in it? Under Szpunar’s proposed test, the facts themselves remain free to report, while access methods and the amount of recognisable expression in an answer may matter to a rights claim.
For publishers, the approach could support challenges where a service gets around access restrictions or provides a close substitute for an article. It does not, on the opinion’s reasoning, create a general right to control every chatbot response that refers to published reporting. For chatbot operators, it points to the importance of respecting website restrictions and avoiding answers that closely reproduce protected expression. The precise legal consequences depend on the final judgment and the facts of each dispute.
Users could also be affected. If services limit close reproductions, they may provide more paraphrased summaries, draw on multiple sources, or direct users to original articles. Those are possible effects, not outcomes specified by the opinion.
Products Worth Considering

LG UltraGear 34GX90SA-W 34-inch WQHD Curved OLED Gaming Monitor

LG UltraGear 32GS60QC-B 32-inch Curved QHD Gaming Monitor (180Hz, 1ms, 1000R, AMD FreeSync, HDR10)

Apple MacBook Air 13-inch Laptop with M5 Chip, 16GB Memory, 512GB SSD, Liquid Retina Display, and Touch ID – Midnight
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
A 2019 Right Meets Chatbots
The case concerns the EU press publishers’ right under Article 15(1) of the 2019 Copyright in the Digital Single Market Directive. The right was adopted to give publishers control over certain online uses of press publications, including uses by news aggregators. The question referred by the Hungarian court is how that framework applies when a chatbot retrieves articles and uses them to answer questions.
The Budapest regional court sent four questions to Luxembourg: two concerning model training and two concerning chatbot answers. Nine EU governments and the European Commission submitted written observations, and the Court of Justice held a hearing on March 10, 2026. The Court describes the case as the first generative AI matter to reach it.
Szpunar treated the training questions differently from the chatbot-answer questions. He advised that the training questions should be declared inadmissible because the record did not show that Like Company’s articles were used to train Gemini. He noted that the disputed article appeared after the model’s training process would likely have begun and said the summary could instead have resulted from live web retrieval, known as retrieval-augmented generation.
For completeness, he discussed the EU text-and-data-mining exception. He considered training generally covered by that exception in principle, subject to rights holders’ ability to opt out in a machine-readable form. That discussion was not his main answer to the training questions, which he said were inadmissible; it should not be read as a ruling that Google trained on these articles.
“The first generative AI case to reach the Court of Justice.”
— The Court of Justice of the European Union, press release No. 155/26
The Final Ruling Is Pending
Szpunar’s opinion is not binding. The Court of Justice’s judges will issue the ruling, and the Hungarian court will then apply EU law to the facts of Like Company’s claim. No date for the Court of Justice judgment has been announced.
Several points remain unresolved. The available account does not establish whether Google’s systems used any Like Company article for model training, and Szpunar said the record did not support that allegation. The final courts will also determine how the proposed test applies to the evidence, including what content Gemini retrieved, what answer it generated, and whether any access controls were bypassed. The opinion’s discussion of text and data mining is advisory analysis, not a final judgment on the scope of the exception in this dispute.
Court Judgment and Hungarian Proceedings
The immediate next step is a judgment from the Court of Justice. Once delivered, it will provide the EU-law interpretation requested by the Hungarian court. The Budapest court will then continue the national case and decide the publisher’s claims against Google in light of that ruling and the evidence.
The Court of Justice has not announced a timetable. Its statistics show preliminary references took an average of 16.9 months in 2025, but that historical figure does not establish when this case will be decided. Until the judgment is issued, the Advocate General’s proposed limits should be treated as influential advice rather than settled law.
Key Questions
Has the EU Court of Justice ruled that Gemini infringed the publisher’s rights?
No. Advocate General Szpunar issued a nonbinding opinion. The judges have yet to issue their ruling, and the Hungarian court must decide the underlying dispute.
When might a chatbot answer infringe publishers’ rights under the opinion?
Szpunar said infringement may arise if a chatbot circumvents access barriers or reproduces a publication’s distinctive expression so recognisably that users can avoid the original. Repeating facts alone is not enough under his proposed test.
Did the opinion find that Google trained Gemini on Like Company articles?
No. The Advocate General said the training questions should be treated as inadmissible because the record did not show that the articles were used for training. His separate discussion of text and data mining was offered for completeness, not as a finding about Google’s training data.
What happens after the Advocate General’s opinion?
The Court of Justice’s judges will issue a judgment interpreting EU law. The Hungarian court will then decide the case based on that interpretation and the evidence. No judgment date has been announced.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
